One of my favorite parts of being a chicken mama is hatching out little peeps. Just to be clear, I don’t hatch them out personally, but I love being a part of the process. Seeing the hens sit so patiently on those eggs for three weeks and then finally hearing the sound of the newborn peeps makes me so excited. I’m in my fourth “peep” season, and I have learned something every year.
This year, we had two broody hens, and we gave each of them about a dozen eggs to sit on. The first hen hatched out four peeps from her clutch, a 40% success rate (a few eggs were broken during incubation). The second hen hatched out three peeps for a 33% success rate. This is a significant decline from previous years. So, I started to wonder what was causing this decline.
Once I see a hen go broody, I will mark the eggs and ensure that she is only sitting on her marked eggs. When a second hen goes broody, I will mark her eggs with a different color. This means I knew the eggs were being incubated for the appropriate amount of time, so that wasn’t the problem.
I wondered if the fault could lie with my sweet rooster, Sven. He has been a great rooster – he isn’t aggressive with me and seems to be nice to the hens. He is a bit aggressive with the few cockerels that have been in the coop over the past two years, but that is to be expected.
Still, the dropping success rate had me wondering. Could it be time for another rooster? Maybe ol’ Sven is past his prime and it is time for a change. Right now, I have two young roosters in the coop with Sven and the hens. One of them is strutting his stuff trying to get to the “ladies,” and the other one seems to be pretty quiet, not making any waves in the coop. I definitely don’t want the “cocky” rooster, as I’ve had enough of that kind of aggressiveness. But I’m considering promoting my quiet rooster to be Sven’s replacement.
There is also another option, and that is to bring in some fresh blood. I haven’t supplemented my flock with any new chickens in nearly three years. And perhaps the inbreeding is causing my issue. Truth be told, people are always wanting to get rid of roosters.
So, here is my dilemma – promote from within or go outside to bring in a fresh perspective? I want to maintain a culture where good behavior is rewarded, but I also want to keep my flock healthy and thriving.
How many of you have faced that dilemma in your business? Promoting from within gives your employees an opportunity to grow within your company, while protecting your tribal knowledge and strengthening your culture. On the other hand, when you bring in someone from the outside, your organization gets a fresh perspective and potentially new approaches to the work you do.
One of my clients was struggling with this very dilemma. The owner wanted to place the right person in the operations seat, but preserving the culture of the company was also important to him. He tried to promote from within, but he couldn’t find the right person who really wanted the seat. So he began searching outside the organization. He found a promising candidate with a lot of great ideas to streamline processes and drive efficiency. But molding the new hire into the existing culture and getting him to embrace those core values was a challenge. It was a bit bumpy for all involved, but over time, the new operations manager smoothed his sharp edges and the employees started to embrace his fresh ideas. Slowly, the team grew closer, and the company became more efficient and, ultimately, more profitable.
If you are facing this issue, consider all the factors and then make a decision that moves you forward. If it turns out to be the wrong decision, you can pivot and try something else. If you need help working through this situation, I can provide an outside perspective to aid you in making the decision.
As for me, I’ve decided to promote from within. I want my current rooster to be given the opportunity to prove his skills. If I don’t end up with a better success rate for hatching out peeps, I will be forced to recruit from outside.